For many medical device and biotech companies, the core expertise lies in developing groundbreaking technologies. However, transitioning from development to production and sales introduces significant risks, particularly regarding product liability. Licensing emerges as an effective strategy to mitigate these risks and accelerate market entry.
The Rising Tide of Product Liability in Medical Devices
Product liability lawsuits in the medical device industry are on the rise. According to recent statistics from 2023, there has been a 15% increase in product liability claims compared to the previous year. Complex and technical medical devices and heightened regulatory oversight contribute to this upward trend.
Case Study: Licensing for Market Success
Consider the case of a clinical-stage biotech company ready to launch its inhaled nitric oxide treatment device. The company recognized the specialized knowledge required to market and use nitric oxide effectively, so it opted for licensing as its go-to-market strategy.
Nitric oxide treatments cater to patients with severe lung infections and pulmonary hypertension, necessitating precise delivery and training capabilities. The biotech company partnered with a pharmaceutical company selling other nitric oxide-related devices. This partner brought essential sales experience, training resources, and support capabilities crucial for market success.
Benefits of the Licensing Strategy
- Faster Market Entry: Under the licensing agreement, the biotech company introduced its device to major healthcare markets in the US and China more rapidly than if it had gone solo.
- Reduced Liability Risks: Licensing allowed the biotech company to avoid significant liability pitfalls in selling a high-risk treatment device.
- Aligned Expertise: The pharmaceutical partner had the expertise to handle necessary training, sales, and support, reducing the risk of improper use and subsequent liability claims.
The Legal Landscape of Product Liability
Liability claims related to injuries from medical devices are a growing concern. Since medical devices increasingly incorporate software and algorithms, the risk of malfunction and resultant harm has become more pronounced. For instance, what happens if a connected medical device delivers an incorrect dose due to a software bug?
Medical device companies must carry comprehensive liability insurance, covering both the device and its use on patients. This insurance must address various potential defects:
- Manufacturing Defects: Incorrect manufacturing processes can lead to product failures.
- Design Defects: Even perfectly manufactured devices can be inherently unsafe if poorly designed.
- Marketing Defects: Inadequate instructions, improper training, or misleading sales practices can expose companies to liability.
FDA Regulatory Oversight and Its Implications
Even after securing FDA clearance, medical devices remain under strict surveillance. The FDA continuously monitors these devices for any liability issues, and any occurrence can trigger regulatory action. Recent advancements in FDA oversight have intensified this scrutiny, making robust liability management strategies more critical.
Licensing as a Shield Against Liability
Licensing offers a strategic shield against product liability. Companies can leverage their partner’s experience and resources by partnering with an established entity. A well-crafted licensing agreement typically includes a product liability indemnification clause, ensuring that the licensing partner will defend against claims arising from device defects or misuse.
Key Advantages of Licensing
- Experienced Sales Force: A seasoned partner can market and sell new devices more effectively.
- Efficient Training: Proper training for healthcare providers is crucial, and an established partner has the expertise to deliver it.
- Insurance and Claims Handling: Licensing partners often have the resources to manage necessary insurance and handle product liability claims efficiently.
- Conclusion
Product liability is a significant challenge in the medical device industry, especially as devices become more sophisticated. Licensing provides a viable solution, offering faster market entry, reduced product liability risks, and access to specialized expertise.
Ready to find out if licensing is the right strategy for your medical device? Schedule a short consulting call today to discuss your IP and licensing options. Together, we can chart a path to market success while safeguarding your innovation.
Rand Brenner is an IP professional whose passion is helping inventors, startups, and businesses use licensing to turn their IP into income-producing products, services, and technologies. His decades of experience run the gamut from medical devices to food technology to consumer products. He’s licensed some of the biggest Hollywood entertainment blockbusters, including the Batman Movies (1 and 2) and the number one kid’s action TV show, the Mighty Morphin Power Rangers. Rand speaks about licensing and is a featured speaker at investment conferences, trade shows, colleges, and startup events. His first book, Hidden Wealth: The Money-Making Power of Licensing, was released in 2019 and is available on Amazon.com. He’s also a published writer, and his articles have appeared in several prestigious trade magazines, including The Licensing Journal, Intellectual Property Magazine, and License India.
Working Through a Licensing or Commercialization Challenge?
If you have market-ready intellectual property, a licensing campaign that has stalled, or a business opportunity that may benefit from licensing, a short strategy discussion can help clarify the next step.